OEA and a half-truth

From John Curry, April 30, 2009

Below is a March 20, 2009 memo from OEA President Patricia Frost-Brooks to OEA District Leaders and OEA Presidents stating (see the yellow highlighted area) Ms. Frost-Brook's apparent disagreement "with bonus payments to investment officers in years when STRS loses money."

Now, please read the two attachments taken from the "approved" STRS Board meeting minutes of March 20, 2009. These two pertinent pages are attached and labeled "XIV" and "XV" and show how three of the OEA's active teacher Board members actually voted on the first round in the voting to accept the "Staff Benefits Committee's recommendation dated March 20, 2009" to temporarily suspend the bonuses. You will notice that the OEA-endorsed active teacher Board members Tim Myers, Mark Meuser and Conni Ramser all voted "no!" The only OEA-endorsed active teacher Board member who cast a "yes" vote to temporarily quash the investment bonuses was Columbus Education Association's Tai Hayden. She is to be congratulated for her courage and insight.

After another vote (see the attachments) and the statement from STRS's Executive Director Nehf that the State Teachers Retirement System staff could live with the suspension of the bonuses did two of the OEA naysayers (Myers and Meuser) finally come around to vote to temporarily freeze the bonuses. Still, on that final vote, OEA's Conni Ramser cast an "abstain" vote. Ms. Frost-Brooks didn't mention, in her letter above, the whole story, did she? What she related was a half truth. Of course, most active educators will not know that, will they? I'm also sure the OEA won't go out of their way to present this documentation to their membership.

John Curry

P.S. Concerning Ms. Frost-Brooks reference to Dr. Dennis Leone as a "dissident board member"....he is "fearful about the financial future of STRS." Well, so is STRS Board candidate Jim Stoll and so should every reader of this email be "fearful about the financial future of STRS." Dr. Leone has curbed more entitlements at STRS during the past four years as a board member than I have fingers and toes. Ms. Frost-Brooks didn't go into specifics on that one either, did she?

From Michael Mahoney, March 20, 2009
To: OEA Board of Directors
OEA District Leaders
OEA Local Presidents
From: OEA Communications and Governmental Services
Re: STRS Bonuses, Investment Performance and Board Elections
Relaying a message from the OEA officers:

STRS Board candidate James Stoll recently distributed an e-mail to many Ohio educators that seeks to further his election campaign by alarming members of STRS about the fund’s market losses and “outrageous” bonuses for employees. STRS lost $33 billion in market value in its most recent fiscal year. The STRS system also paid bonuses to 83 employees for outperforming the market - losing less than comparable funds.

The Ohio Education Association is deeply concerned about STRS market losses. OEA does not agree with bonuses payments to investment officers in years when STRS loses money. As a result, OEA commends the recent vote by the STRS board to suspend 2009 bonuses, as well as formation of a board committee of the whole to address investment performance. However, OEA feels strongly that Mr. Stoll’s recent e-mail was a cynical exploitation of the emotions of educators, including a quote from dissident board member Dennis Leone, in an attempt to make them fearful about the financial future of STRS and cast a vote for Stoll.

During comments to promote his candidacy during the public participation period at the STRS board meeting this week, another odd practice, Stoll boasted he has a list of 145,000 educator e-mail addresses, presumably to further his campaign. Earlier, he had sued to obtain e-mail addresses from STRS, but the Ohio Supreme Court declined to hear his case, upholding a policy to protect the privacy of member e-mail.

OEA has recommended the election Stoll’s opponent, Carol Correthers of the Lorain Education Association, to the active STRS board seat. We believe she has the temperament, qualifications and judgment to serve on the board.

Stoll never sought OEA’s recommendation and did not go to an OEA screening. Moreover his recent e-mail confirms our position. OEA must address this situation, but we apologize for any inconvenience our e-mail to you may cause. If you do not want to receive further e-mails on this subject, please click here or send your request to communic@ohea.org.

Cc: All OEA Staff
Click images to enlarge.

.................................................................................

And OEA insists they legally do not and cannot tell STRS Board members what to do and how to vote: yet we know they do from STRS Board members -- though fearful of even saying it publicly.

~ Molly Janczyk